kimberly-sutanto
Pope Leo XIV concluded a four-day apostolic journey to France with a farewell ceremony at Metz–Nancy–Lorraine Airport in Goin, northeastern France, where he and President Emmanuel Macron reviewed troops in an official departure protocol on September 28, 2026. The visit culminated in the eastern city of Metz, the hometown of Maurice Schumann, a founding figure of present-day European federalism, a symbolic backdrop for a pontiff making an explicit case for European integration.
During his time in Metz, the head of the world's largest organized religion publicly affirmed that Europe's roots are Christian, tracing that heritage back to the Romans. At the same time, he praised a European Union model that he said rises above "us versus them" thinking, rejecting the notion that "might is right" in favor of human rights and international law as organizing principles for the continent.
The pope's message positions him in direct tension with France's far-right movement, which has long framed itself as a defender of Christian civilization. Analysts and commentators have seized on the contrast between Leo's universalist brand of Catholicism and the eurosceptic nationalism espoused by French presidential frontrunner Marine Le Pen and Jordan Bardella, the leader of her National Rally party.
That clash of values arrives at a politically charged moment. A recent poll showed Le Pen widening her lead ahead of the 2027 presidential vote, underscoring the far right's continued momentum in France. The same political current has been making inroads just across the border in neighboring Germany, raising questions about how much moral authority the pope and the Catholic Church can realistically exercise in 2026.
The debate program examining the visit brought together four guests to unpack its significance: Elena Pompei, an ENTR journalist; Yves Sintomer, professor of political science at Paris 8 University; Christine Pedotti, director of the French Christian weekly publication "Témoignage chrétien"; and Andrea Antonio Verardi, professor of church history at the Pontifical Gregorian University. Their discussion framed the trip as more than a ceremonial tour, treating it as an intervention in a live European argument over identity, sovereignty and rights.
One central question the panel weighed was how Leo's version of Catholicism squares with a eurosceptic far right that continues to gain ground in France and Germany. By grounding European values in Christian heritage while simultaneously endorsing the EU's legal and human-rights framework, the pope appeared to reclaim a vocabulary that nationalist movements have often used for exclusionary ends.
Beyond the ideological confrontation, the visit also confronted the Church's own institutional failures. During his four-day tour, Leo met privately with victims of abuse and acknowledged the damage inflicted by systemic abuse within the Church. That acknowledgment, kept largely out of public view, added a somber counterpoint to the enthusiastic crowds that greeted him elsewhere.
Those crowds were substantial, according to the source account, with the pope drawing huge numbers of people during his travels across France. The scale of the turnout suggests that despite declining institutional adherence in much of Europe, the papal office retains a rare capacity to mobilize public attention around moral and political questions.
The choice of Metz for the trip's final stop carried layered meaning. As the hometown of Schumann, a founding father of European federalism, the city served as a physical reminder of the post-war project of integration that the pope implicitly defended. His remarks there effectively placed the Church's moral weight behind that project at a time when it faces sustained pressure from nationalist parties.
Leo's framing of Europe's Christian roots is likely to be contested from multiple directions. For the far right, the pope's insistence on human rights and international law over "might is right" undercuts claims that Christianity and national identity are interchangeable. For secular critics, his invocation of Christian heritage may raise concerns about the role of religion in shaping public life on a pluralistic continent.
The political calendar adds urgency to the debate. With Le Pen leading in polling ahead of the 2027 presidential race and Bardella's National Rally continuing to shape French political discourse, the pope's visit places him, whether by design or not, in the middle of a contest over what Europe stands for. His message of dialogue and peace, delivered as the trip closed with a plea for Europe to foster both, reads as a direct challenge to the politics of division.
How the visit will be remembered remains an open question. It combined three distinct elements: a firm defense of European integration and international law, a private reckoning with the Church's abuse crisis, and a popular outpouring that demonstrated the pope's continued public appeal. Together they suggest a pontiff attempting to position the Church as a moral reference point in a polarized era.
The panel's discussion also raised a broader question about the limits of papal influence. Even as Leo draws crowds and commands headlines, the far-right parties he implicitly criticizes continue to advance electorally in France and Germany. That gap between moral authority and electoral outcomes will likely define assessments of the visit's long-term impact.
For now, the images of the farewell ceremony in Goin, with the pope and Macron reviewing troops before his departure, close a trip that was as much political as pastoral. Leo XIV leaves France having stated clearly where he believes Europe's foundations lie, and having implicitly asked its voters to weigh that vision against the nationalist alternative gaining strength across the continent.
Comments (0)